Indus Lex is always happy to serve you with professional judicial drafting services.

⚖️ Professional Drafting | Legally Precise | Timely Delivery

Are You Husband ?

If You are husband and your wife has filed multiples cases against you then this is must read article for you.

CRIMINAL LAWS

Vikrant Pratap Singh Advocate

9/28/20263 min read

If You Are a Husband and Your Wife Has Lodged Multiple Cases Against You, There Is No Need to Panic

If you are a husband and your wife has lodged multiple criminal cases against you and your family members arising out of a matrimonial dispute, there is no need to panic. The law provides several remedies to protect you and your family members from unnecessary harassment and abuse of the criminal process.

First, if an F.I.R. has been lodged against you and other members of your family in connection with a matrimonial dispute, you may challenge the F.I.R. before the appropriate High Court by invoking its inherent jurisdiction. However, merely because an F.I.R. has been lodged does not mean that the entire prosecution will automatically be quashed. The Court examines the allegations, the material collected during investigation and the facts and circumstances of each individual case. Where the allegations are found to be vague, inherently improbable, malicious, or amount to an abuse of the process of law, the High Court may exercise its inherent jurisdiction to quash the proceedings.

Second, it is important to understand the law relating to arrest in offences punishable with imprisonment up to seven years. In Satender Kumar Antil v. Central Bureau of Investigation, the Hon'ble Supreme Court emphasized the statutory safeguards governing arrest and the need for the police to apply their mind to the necessity of arrest. Therefore, the mere registration of an F.I.R. in an offence punishable up to seven years does not mean that the accused must necessarily be arrested. The police are required to act in accordance with the law and the safeguards contained in the Code of Criminal Procedure, as applicable to the case.

In matrimonial disputes, therefore, the accused should not assume that registration of an F.I.R. automatically results in arrest. At the same time, it would also be legally incorrect to say that the police have absolutely no power to arrest in every offence punishable up to seven years. The circumstances of each case and the statutory requirements governing arrest have to be considered.

Third, after registration of the F.I.R., the accused may adopt an appropriate legal strategy depending upon the facts of the case. Where the allegations themselves disclose no offence, are manifestly absurd or inherently improbable, or where the criminal proceedings appear to have been initiated with an ulterior motive to harass the accused, the accused may approach the High Court for appropriate relief, including quashing of the F.I.R. In other cases, the accused may allow the investigation to proceed and contest the matter at the appropriate stage.

If, after investigation, the police submit a charge-sheet and the competent Magistrate takes cognizance of the alleged offences, the accused may still have an appropriate remedy before the High Court. If the charge-sheet and the material collected during investigation do not disclose the commission of an offence, or if continuation of the criminal proceedings would amount to an abuse of the process of law, the High Court may exercise its inherent jurisdiction to quash the proceedings, subject to the facts and circumstances of the case.

In matrimonial disputes, the Hon'ble High Courts and the Hon'ble Supreme Court may, in appropriate cases, encourage the parties to explore the possibility of settlement through mediation. Where the dispute is essentially matrimonial in nature and the parties are willing to resolve their differences, mediation can sometimes provide a practical and peaceful solution. Depending upon the facts of the case, the Court may also stay further proceedings while the parties explore settlement.

It is also important to understand that mediation is a voluntary process. In some cases, the parties may arrive at a settlement involving payment of a mutually agreed amount or other terms. However, there is no fixed rule that an accused must pay money to obtain quashing, and the terms of settlement depend entirely upon the facts of the case and the consent of the parties. If mediation fails, the criminal proceedings do not automatically come to an end. The Court may thereafter consider the matter on its merits and determine whether the proceedings deserve to continue or be quashed in accordance with law.

Therefore, if you or your family members are facing multiple criminal cases arising out of a matrimonial dispute, the correct approach is not to panic but to understand the allegations, examine the legal remedies available at each stage, and obtain appropriate legal advice at the earliest opportunity.

Every matrimonial criminal case is fact-specific. Therefore, no person should assume that an F.I.R. will automatically be quashed, that arrest is legally impossible, or that mediation will necessarily result in settlement. The appropriate remedy depends upon the allegations, the offences invoked, the evidence collected and the stage of the proceedings.